Comparison
Participation software: open source or SaaS?
Self-host with Decidim or CONSUL — or use a hosted platform? An honest comparison of both routes, so you find the right one for your project.
Anyone looking for a participation platform quickly faces a fundamental question: run an open-source solution like Decidim or CONSUL yourself — or use ready-hosted software (SaaS)? Both can reach the goal, but they differ markedly in effort, cost and responsibility.
The short answer: open source offers maximum control and customisability but demands technical resources for operation, maintenance and security. SaaS is ready in minutes and is run for you — within a defined scope. The overview below makes the differences concrete.
Open source vs. SaaS at a glance
| Criterion | Open source (self-hosted) | SaaS (hosted) |
|---|---|---|
| License cost | Free (open source) | Subscription, often with a free tier |
| Operation & hosting | Your responsibility (server, ops) | Included in the price |
| Setup effort | High — installation & configuration | Minutes to ready |
| Maintenance & updates | Apply yourself (incl. security) | Automatic by the provider |
| Customisability | Very high (full source code) | Within the settings |
| Technical know-how | Required (IT/development) | Not needed |
| Data protection & hosting location | Fully self-determined | Depends on the provider — ask |
| Support | Community / service provider | Directly from the provider |
What fits your project?
Open source fits if …
- you have your own IT resources for operation and maintenance
- maximum customisation and full data access are a must
- special procedures need deep individualisation
- long-term in-house development is planned
SaaS fits if …
- you want to start quickly without IT effort
- you want to hand off operation, updates and security
- predictable costs matter more than deep individualisation
- the focus is on participation rather than technology
Where MyIdeas stands
MyIdeas is a hosted SaaS solution focused on a fast start and low operation: ready in minutes, hosting in Germany, GDPR-compliant without a cookie banner, and with a Starter plan that is free forever. We handle operation, updates and security — you focus on participation.
Frequently asked questions
Isn’t open source always cheaper?
The license is free, operation is not: servers, setup, updates, security and support cost time and money. Once you include this total cost of ownership, SaaS is cheaper and more predictable for many organisations.
Can I later switch from SaaS to open source — or vice versa?
In principle yes — what matters is that content can be exported. With any solution, check the export options so you are not locked into one provider.
What about data protection?
With open source you determine the hosting location yourself. With SaaS it depends on the provider — ask about hosting location and data processing. MyIdeas hosts in Germany and works without a cookie banner.
You might also like
Ready in minutes — no operations
Try the hosted participation platform free for 14 days. Starter free forever.